Spaghetti competitions in Budapest, organized by the Department of Mechanics & Structures: 1989 – 2009

Back to main

 

Having learned from and built on the experience of spaghetti competitions in the United Kingdom in the 1980s, the main objectives of the Department of Mechanics and Structures for organizing spaghetti competitions were to help the students to

 

  • see the relationship between theory and practice
  • develop their own feel for construction
  • understand the importance of models in structural analysis
  • get “real-life” experience in structural design and construction
  • learn about the practical problems of creating efficient and economic structures
  • unearth their intuitiveness

 

using the relatively simple task of creating a spaghetti structure (and to have fun in the meantime).

 

The intention of the Department was to achieve all these objectives in a “family atmosphere” with no external influence and commercial interest whatsoever. The organizers tried to rely on simple means in keeping the fairly complicated process of loading, measuring and presentation at the simplest possible level. The feedback from each competition between 1989 and 2009 made the organizers become more and more confident that their aim was true.

 

The first spaghetti competition in Hungary (and probably in Eastern/Central Europe) in 1989

 

 

Karoly Zalka: announcing the results

The Institution of Structural Engineers (UK): the trophy

 

 

 

Gábor Makai’s winning model

Gábor Makai receives the ISE trophy from Graham Armer (ISE)

 

 

 

Runner-up by Éva Varga & Katalin Horváth

Éva Varga & Katalin Horváth with Lajos Pozsgai

 

 

 

Gergely Kádár in third place

Gergely Kádár and Lajos Pozsgai

 

 

 

Gyula Erőss in fourth place

Gyula Erőss and Károly Zalka

 

 

 

Tamás Fekete and Gyula Erőss in fifth place

Tamás Fekete receives his certificate from Károly Zalka with Lajos Pozsgai looking on

 

 

 

No.6: Kolos Marcell

No. 7: Tamás Fekete and Gyula Erőss

 

 

 

No.8: István Sass

No.9: András Stermeczky

 

 

 

No.10: Gergely Kádár

No.11: András Stermeczky and Zoltán Ritter

 

 

 

 

 

No.12: Ferenc Tátrai

.

.

.

.

... and 20 years and 18 competitions later ...

.

.

.

.

The last spaghetti competition (2009)

(Most of the pictures are snapshots from the video recording made and kindly supplied by Attila Prepuk)

 

 

 

 

The winning model before and during loading

The winner: Attila Prepuk with the ISE trophy

 

 

 

Winning model in preparation

 

 

 

Runner-up before loading and at collapse

“Csodalámpa” in second place

 

 

 

“Zúzmó” in third place: before loading and one second from collapse

“Zúzmó”, creator of a textbook example of pure torsional buckling, receiving the third-prize certificate

 

 

    

    

    

    

 

“Tripod” at No.4

No. 5: “Pan”

 

 

    

    

    

    

 

No.6: “Eltoltuk”

No. 7: “Stan”

 

 

    

    

    

    

 

No. 8: “Bábel2009”

No.9: “Pozor Stavenisko!”

 

 

    

    

    

    

 

No. 10: “Vízmű”

No. 11: “Kocka” - was it inclined even before loading?

 

 

    

    

    

    

 

No.12: “Bolonyai rendszer” underperforming

No. 13: “Tégla” in classic lateral buckling

 

 

 

 

 

No. 14: “Oktatássy reeform” in last place ...

 

 

The eighteen competitions: a summary

 

No.

date

type of structure

name of model

name of winner

course/year

1.

1989

tower

Reccs N

Gábor Makai

Civil Eng/1

2.

1991

tower with

enforcement

Úgyis megússzuk

Zoltán Borbély

Tibor Mészáros

László Bánhidi

Civil Eng/3

Civil Eng/3

Civil Eng/2

 

 

tower without

enforcement

Ne mozdulj

Miklós Hajdú

Éva Szilágyi

Zita Eördögh

Civil Eng/1

Civil Eng/1

Civil Eng/1

3.

1991

bridge

Pie Bridge

Tibor Kálnai

Árpád Urbán

Civil Eng/1

Civil Eng/1

4.

1992

tower

HANOI

Attila Koltai

Urban Eng/2

5.

1993

tower

Ferrobond

Csaba Kelemen

Sándor Dilong

Urban Eng/3

Civil Eng/1

6.

1995

cantilever

MEA

Krisztina Reményi

Vilmos Fülöp

Civil Eng/3

Civil Eng/3

7.

1998

bridge

HETTI-D-20

István Erdélyi

Andrea Bencze

Civil Eng/1

Urban Eng/1

8.

1999

tower

3.728.932.565. a

szerencseszámok

Sándor Zajzon

Tamás Czapp

Architect/1

Architect/1

9.

2000

bridge

Saciki

Tamás Czapp

Ágnes Kanozsai

Sándor Zajzon

Architect/2

Architect/2

Architect/2

10.

2001

bridge

KiTartó

Ágnes Kanozsai

Tamás Czapp

Architect/2

Architect/2

11.

2002

bridge

Merlin

Balázs Bökönyszegi

Róbert Gróz

BMF-BDGFK

12.

2003

bridge

Xenosz

András Köves

BMF-BGK

13.

2004

bridge

Durung

Béla Kozma

Martin Scheidl

PSZF

BME/Ybl Arch.

14.

2005

tower

JAFFA

Gábor Járási

Judit Lajkó

Civil Eng/3

Manager/1

15.

2006

tower

Boby

Miklós Margaritovits

Gábor Veres

Civil Eng/3

Manager/4

16.

2007

frame

Etalon II

Eszter Friedl

Gábor Fekete

Civil Engineer

Civil Engineer

17.

2008

frame

Made in Hungary

Attila Prepuk

Civil Engineer

18.

2009

tower

Csak egy Mecha 2-est!

Attila Prepuk

Civil Engineer

 

 

 

Grateful thanks are extended to the members of the Department of Mechanics and Structures in general and to László Gálhidy and Péter Freund in particular

 

 

Without László (1989–2009), this project would never have left the level of wishful thinking; with Péter’s enthusiasm and innovative approach (2001–2009), the value of the project increased considerably

 

Back to top                   Back to main